Re-reading the programme notes for Cecilia Bartoli's concert on Wednesday, I did rather find myself disagreeing with the writer (Christopher Cook) on the subject of Handel's Giulio Cesare. He refers to the way that 'Handel and his librettist blend the serious with the comic', going on to refer to Cleopatra as 'playful, funny, teasing and an unscrupulous operator'. I would certainly agree with the second comment, as that is what makes Cleopatra so charming, but I would have to disagree with the first comment, I don't think there is actually anything specifically funny in the libretto. Handel certainly didn't do funny, his lighter operas can have a rather satirical bent, but never outright comedy. Giulio Cesare belongs to the first Academy period, when Handel was doing operas of high seriousness; mainly, it seems likely, because that is what his aristocratic backers on the Academy board wanted. Nowadays, producers rather add a comic element to these operas, both the Glyndebourne Rodelinda and the Glyndebourne Giulio Cesare had crowd pleasing comic elements which have no place in the music. So no, I don't think the opera blends serious with comic.
The article then goes on to describe the scene when Cleopatra sings V'adoro, pupille as 'perhaps owes as much to a Soho burlesque at The Windmill as it does to ancient Parnassus'. Really? Obviously I have a far more serious view of the opera than Christopher Cook, but that raises the question of who is right. Because I put Handel's music on something of a pedestal, am I right in attributing motives of high seriousness to the opera productions. Was the original Parnassus scene viewed as being a little risqué? Surely the care which Handel lavished on the orchestration, with the on-stage orchestra of muses specified as having 9 instruments, mitigates against the idea that the scene had a burlesque element.
Sunday, 12 December 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts this month
-
Grieg: Lyric Pieces, Op. 71 , Moods, Op. 73, Peer Gynt Suite, Op. 46 , transcriptions of Songs, Op. 41 - Alexander Ullmann - Rubicon Cla...
-
Having recorded a disc of motets by Francois Couperin (see my review ), Edward Higginbottom and the choir of New College Oxford have turne...
-
Britten: Albert Herring - Dan D'Souza, Caspar Singh - ENO 2025 (Photo: Genevieve Girling) Britten: Albert Herring ; Caspar Singh, Emma...
-
Gimnazija Kranj Symphony Orchestra I get all sorts of mail, people sending my information on concerts and recordings. Everything gets gl...
-
Schubert: Trout Quintet - Mikhail Kopelman, Loïc Rio, Laurent Marfaing, François Kieffer, Grigory Kovalevsky, Elisabeth Leonskaja (Photo ©...
-
Mark Rogers, Hugo Brady - Oxford International Song Festival (Photo: TallWall Media) Moore's Melodies : traditional, Stanford, Ina Boyle...
-
The Magdalene Songs - Deirdre Brenner, Lotte Betts-Dean - Oxford International Song Festival (Photo: TallWall Media) The Magdalene Songs : ...
-
Baba Yaga: Songs & Dances of Death - Sholto Kynoch, Ana Dordevic, Carola Schwab, Rowan Hellier - Oxford International Song Festival (Ph...
-
Bach: Mass in B Minor - Peter Whelan, Irish Baroque Orchestra & Choir, Christ Church Cathedral, Dublin Bach: Mass in B minor; Rachel R...
-
Schwanengesang - Thomas Oliemans at Oxford International Song Festival Schubert Weekend: Nikola Hillebrand, Julius Drake, Thomas Oliemans, P...
No comments:
Post a Comment