Gilbert & Sullivan: HMS Pinafore - Marcus Farnsworth, Elgan Llyr Thomas, Ossian Huskinson - English National Opera (Photo Marc Brenner) |
Gilbert & Sullivan HMS Pinafore; Les Dennis, John Savournin, Elgan Llyr Thomas, Alexandra Oomens, Hilary Summers, dir: Cal McCrystal, cond: Chris Hopkins; English National Opera at the London Coliseum
Reviewed by Robert Hugill on 29 October 2021 Star rating: (★★★★)
Physical comedy, running gags and Les Dennis, Cal McCrystal's new production is finely sung but somewhat over busy yet undeniably entertaining
Having given us a joyous production of Gilbert & Sullivan's Iolanthe at English National Opera in 2018 [see my review] director Cal McCrystal returned with a further G&S for the company's first new production of the 2021/22 season. Cal McCrystal's production of HMS Pinafore opened at English National Opera on 29 October 2021 with Les Dennis as Sir Joseph Porter, John Savournin as Captain Corcoran, Elgan Llyr Thomas as Ralph Rackstraw, Henry Waddington as Dick Deadeye, Marcus Farnsworth as Bill Bobstay, Ossian Huskinson as Bob Becket, Alexandra Oomens as Josephine, Bethan Langford as Hebe and Hilary Summers as Buttercup. Chris Hopkins conducted, designs were by takis, and choreography by Lizzi Gee.
HMS Pinafore was only the second full-length collaboration between Gilbert and Sullivan and its humour is perhaps somewhat softer-edged than the later operas. The premise is less crazily topsy-turvy, and the work's poking fun at class and crony-dom seems to lack the satirical weight of later pieces. Cal McCrystal took a traditional very of the setting, and takis' designs gave us a very traditional poop-deck and period costuming, but within this McCrystal brought a whole armoury of comic gags to bear, to increase the laughter rate. So much so, that you felt he never quite trusted either Gilbert's text or Sullivan's music.
Gilbert & Sullivan: HMS Pinafore - ENO Chorus with Spencer Darlaston-Jones mid-air - English National Opera (Photo Marc Brenner) |
There were running gags - Flick Ferdinando as an elderly aunt constantly appearing at the wrong moment; a mini-me sidekick for John Savournin's Captain Corcoran in the form of Midshipmite Tom Tucker played by juvenile actor Rufus Bateman (all of nine years old) in scene-stealing form. There was over-egging the visuals including all sorts of flying interruptions during the music, from birds to Boris Johnson, there was a wide variety of extra jokes, often pushing the humour in the direction of rudery foreign to Gilbert's oeuvre, plus an amazing acrobatic sailor (Spencer Darlaston-Jones as the athletic Sergeant of Marines), scantily clad sailors and tap number opening Act Two, with John Savournin, Rufus Bateman, Marcus Farnsworth and Les Dennis all donning their tap shoes.
McCrystal is a fine director and much of this was very funny, but unlike his production of Iolanthe, a lot of it felt added on and foreign to the drama, and his tendency to pull focus during the opera's more serious and understated numbers smacked of a crowd-pleasing distrust of Sullivan's music. The cast, however, entered into the hi-jinks with a will and the result was a well sung and entertaining evening in the theatre, albeit with the strong reservation that it could have been a more effective if McCrystal had shown greater trust in the piece.
What McCrystal missed out of the mix was melodrama.