Out of the Shadows

Wednesday, 4 August 2021

From Silence: Franz Welser-Möst's autobiography is a thoughtful meditation on the conductor's craft

Franz Welser-Möst From Silence: Finding Calm in a Dissonant World; Clearview Books

Franz Welser-Möst From Silence: Finding Calm in a Dissonant World; Clearview Books

Reviewed by Robert Hugill on 3 August 2021 Star rating: 4.0 (★★★★)
A thoughtful, poetic yet trenchant meditation on the music and its role in today's society

Conductor Franz Welser-Möst's book From Silence: Finding Calm in a Dissonant World is not quite an autobiography, though it is autobiographical in a sense as it is the conductor's meditations on the role of the conductor seen through the prism of his experiences. Written with Axel Bruggemann and translated by Christine Shuttleworth the book is published in the UK by Clearview Books.

It is a very poetic book, Welser-Möst takes a considered and thoughtful view of his craft, there are strong opinions here but also a feeling of the more mystical elements of music making. We begin in silence, with a profoundly serious car accident that Welser-Möst had when he was 18. And throughout the book, the sections on the conductor's craft are interleaved with meditations on types of silence, from the meditative to journeying up a mountain.

Welser-Möst's narrative interleaves his own personal development with passages about the role of the conductor and of music today, so that each time the young Franz moves on the older one thinks about what this means. There are trenchant views here, particularly about the role a conductor might play and the wider role of music in the light of his experience heading up the Cleveland Orchestra.

 'I must confess that I sometimes feel like a stranger in this loud and euphoric world, in which so much is dealt with on the surface and so little in depth'.

Many times during the book Welser-Möst feels like this bemused stranger, yet there are highly practical considerations too. He is thoughtful about the role of music and musicians in society, 'I have learned much in the USA, above all that it is important repeatedly to address the relevance and self-concept of an institution such as an orchestra'. Repeatedly we come back to questions of competence, relevance and craftsmanship, whether in opera or the concert hall.

'The whole company in a piano dress rehearsal should not have to deal with the question of how the dead Commendatore in Don Giovanni actually gets off stage'.

Quite often, underneath this poetic and thoughtful prose we can detect the rather serious, intense and somewhat unyielding man, who thinks deeply and holds opionions strongly. Yet always, we feel that his dedication is not to himself but the music, and he decries the modern tendency to self-promotion.

The problematic areas are here too. The episode in London is dealt with fairly frankly, and we get a feel for his sense of propriety and what is proper, even as a young man who certainly was not the yielding and malleable young conductor that the orchestral management expected. Similarly, he deals with the collapse of his relationship with the intendant in Zurich, whilst being clear and positive about what they achieved.

'For me it is the expression of a populist attitude when an interpretation is aimed at instant appeal and it is merely a question of who can play a work in the most extreme, exaggerated way'

His chapter 'On the production of sound' has some intriguing thoughts about the post-war generation of conductors, Bernstein, Karajan, Celibidache, their approach and what they achieved as figures of authority. 'I find it strange when orchestras today still want to be conducted by such domineering personalities ... Making music today can only be done in a spirit of togetherness.'

This section also includes thoughtful considerations of music itself, focusing on Beethoven's Ninth Symphony and Strauss' Der Rosenkavalier. But we finish with a final meditation on silence, that on the brink of eternity.





Never miss out on future posts by following us

The blog is free, but I'd be delighted if you were to show your appreciation by buying me a coffee.

Elsewhere on this blog
  • Antonio José incompleto: a portrait of the Spanish composer killed in 1936  - record review
  • Admired by Berlioz and Wagner, the operas of Gaspare Spontini were hugely influential in their day yet are still a rarity on the modern operatic stage  - feature
  • A strong affinity for Russian music: I chat to pianist Sonya Bach about her recent Rachmaninov disc, studying with Lazar Berman and more  - interview
  • Engaging, imaginative and beautifully thought out: four online recitals from Robin Tritschler, Jess Dandy, Julien van Mellaerts, Harriet Burns and Ian Tindale - online review
  • American Quintets: Kaleidescope Chamber Collective's debut recording features the 1st recording of a mature Florence Price work alongside Amy Beach and Samuel Barber  - record review
  • Piazzolla explorations: celebrating the composer's centenary with recordings from Lithuania, Switzerland and the USA  - record review
  • Janacek's The Diary of One Who Disappeared alongside his Moravian songs and Dvorak's Gypsy Songs from Nicky Spence, Fleur Barron, Dylan Perez and friends at Opera Holland Park  - concert review
  • A light touch, yet full of character: Mascagni's L'amico Fritz proves an engaging discovery at Opera Holland Park - opera review
  • To focus on the journey, on the people and their stories: Julia Burbach directs Wagner's Die Walküre for the Grimeborn Festival - interview
  • Janacek's forest could easily be on a London estate around the corner from the theatre: The Cunning Little Vixen at Opera Holland Park - opera review
  • The piece conveys the idea that women should be listened to: composer Gráinne Mulvey & soprano Elizabeth Hilliard chat about their latest collaboration Great Women  - interview
  • Seven Ages: Mark Padmore, Roderick Williams, Julius Drake, Victoria Newlyn at Temple Music  - concert review
  • The Call: six young artists showcased in the first recital disc from Momentum  - record review
  • Home

No comments:

Post a Comment

Popular Posts this month