On Saturday morning, Berta Joncus discussed recent Handel recordings on the CD Review programme on BBC Radio 3. Here selection of recordings included Handel's Alcina from the Bavarian State Opera under Ivor Bolton and Danielle de Niese's recent recital record with William Christie and Les Arts Florissants. Joncus played de Niese's account of Tornami a vagheggiar and compared it with the same aria from the Bavarian State Opera recording. She complained that de Niese's version was slower and heaver than the Bavarian account, suggesting that de Niese sang this music with an essentially 19th century type technique, adding that on stage de Niese's personality was dazzling so that you forgave her these musical issues, but that on disc the problems were more noticeable.
It was interesting to hear somebody articulate what I had felt about de Niese's singing. As soon as Joncus made her comments I realised that it made a great deal of sense to me. There are number of singers on the circuit, David Daniels is another, who often seem to attach the baroque repertoire in the same way that they would sing Rossini. It seems that for much of the time this goes uncommented.
Monday, 2 June 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts this month
-
Having recorded a disc of motets by Francois Couperin (see my review ), Edward Higginbottom and the choir of New College Oxford have turne... -
Carl Heinrich Graun Carl Heinrich Graun: opera arias; Valer Sabadus, {oh!} Orkiestra, Martyna Pastuszka; Bayreuth Baroque Opera Festival at ... -
Elgar: The Kingdom ; Francesca Chiejina, Sarah Connolly, Benjamin Hulett, Ashley Riches, Crouch End Festival Chorus, Hertfordshire Chorus, L... -
London, ca.1740: Handel's musicians : Charles Weideman, Giuseppe Sammartini, Pietro Castrucci, George Frideric Handel, James Oswald; L... -
Handel, Corelli, Sammartini, Geminiani, Castrucci, Blow, Smith; Olwen Foulkes, Nathaniel Mander, Carina Drury, Toby Carr, Tabea Debus;... -
David Allinson and The Renaissance Singers at Holy Sepulchre London, The Renaissance Singers is a chamber choir with a difference. One of Lo... -
Manuscript score, signed by the composer and the performers of the premiere One of England’s greatest choral works, Elgar’s The Dream of Ger... -
Julian Chan The Royal Academy of Music’s Bicentenary Series on Linn Records offers industry-level recording experience and the chance to r... -
The Stationers' Hall where Purcell's Hail, Bright Cecilia was premiered in 1692 Humfrey: O Lord my God , Blow: I was glad , Purcell:... -
Love and Loss: Elena Firsova, Dmitri Smirnov; Rudersdal Chamber Players; OUR Recordings Reviewed 15 December 2025 The Danish contemporary m...
You don't precisely define the "problem" of singing Handel with a "19th Century technique" (whatever that might be). If you mean that de Niese and David Daniels sing legato and allow their voices to vibrate naturally, I can only wonder why you think it a problem. Some of us would rather not hear the vibratoless marcato yodeling usually passes for Baroque singing, and we find the tendency of the newer singers like de NIese and Daniels to engage in something more or less recognizable as mainstream operatic singing anything but a problem!
ReplyDelete