Anna Dennis |
Handel: Susanna; Anna Dennis, Alexander Chance, Jessica Cale, Joshua Ellicott, Matthew Brook, Dunedin Consort, John Butt; Church of St Martin in the Fields
Reviewed 24 January 2025
Given complete, this wonderfully involving account of Handel's woefully neglected Susanna revealed why the work should be considered alongside his other masterpieces
Whilst we talk of Handelian oratorio, the composer's own conception of the genre rarely stood still. From 1739 to 1745, his sequence of oratorios consisted of Saul, Israel in Egypt, L'Allegro, Messiah, Samson, Semele, Joseph and his Brethren, Hercules and Belshazzar. Presenting us with a remarkable breadth when it comes to trying to pin down what exactly 'oratorio' meant to its creator. Of course, in 1745, external events intruded and for the next few years, Handel's works veered towards to martial and bellicose.
By 1749, he clearly felt enough time had passed to look elsewhere. That year, he premiered two new works, Susanna and Solomon, both works take a somewhat oblique approach to the conventions of dramatic oratorio. Rather coincidentally, both works have received recent London performances, giving us a chance to compare and contrast. Earlier this month, Paul McCreesh directed the Gabriel Consort & Players in Handel's Solomon [see my review], then on Friday 24 January 2025, John Butt directed the Dunedin Consort in Handel's Susanna at the Church of St Martin in the Fields.
Another link between Susanna and Solomon is Handel's casting. The mezzo-soprano Caterina Galli sang both Solomon and Joacim in Susanna, whilst soprano Giulia Frasi sang the three soprano roles in Solomon and the title role in Susanna. Rather intriguingly for modern-day London audiences, soprano Anna Dennis was common to both the recent Handel performances, singing the Queen of Sheba in Solomon for Paul McCreesh, and then singing the title role in Handel's Susanna for John Butt and the Dunedin Consort. She was joined by Alexander Chance as Joacim, Jessica Cale as Daniel (and an attendant), Joshua Ellicott and Matthew Brook as the elders.