As an experiment we have the first in a planned series of guest postings from The Arts Desk.
This week The Arts Desk’s classical music reviewers took in a wealth of choral music and paid a frightening visit to
Bluebeard’s castle.
On Thursday evening, Edward Seckerson
headed to the Royal Festival Hall for a semi-staged performance of
Bartók’s Duke Bluebeard’s Castle by the Philharmonia Orchestra
under Esa-Pekka Salonen, as part of their Bartók season entitled Infernal
Dance. After a first half of Debussy and Bartók’s Third Piano Concerto, played
with disappointingly little personality by Yefim Bronfman, the audience was
taken to Bluebeard’s castle. Seckerson was firmly of the opinion that this
operatic masterpiece needed no form of staging, no choreography, to hammer home
the disturbing images it evokes, a sentiment borne out as the projected images
of condensation droplets and blood seeping through a cloth added nothing to the
atmosphere and psychology of the piece, and if anything only impeded the
imagination. Thankfully the quality of the musical interpretation made up for
this needless distraction: John Tomlinson and Michelle DeYoung were
extraordinary in the lead roles and, in full command of their vocals and the
interior world of their characters did all the visual conjuring work that was
necessary.
As something for the weekend, Graham
Rickson chose to focus on three discs of choral music in The Arts Desk’s pick
of the week’s most interesting classical CD
releases. The first was a recording of Fauré’s Requiem by the Orchestre de
Paris under Paavo Järvi. The revelation of this recording was that it refreshed
a stale work tarnished by its own popularity. Rickson was able to appreciate
anew the understated nature of the piece, and the warmth, consolation and
sincerity it emits, especially in countertenor Phillippe Jaroussky’s solo Pie
Jesu. The accompanying pieces were also a pleasure, including a rare
performance of Fauré’s unusually bold psalm setting Super flumina
Babylonis. Rickson’s second selection was in fact a classical DVD of Riccardo
Chailly’s Gewandhausorchester filmed performing Mahler’s Eighth Symphony, which
amply met Rickson’s criteria of being well directed (by Michael Beyer),
superbly performed and boasting excellent sound quality. Chailly is clearly
having fun with the more peculiar elements of Mahler’s work, leading a
consistently strong ensemble with his dynamic, positive conducting, making it
an all the more accessible, coherent and affirmative experience. Rickson’s
final disc of the week was In the Beginning by the Choir of
Merton College, Oxford, a collection of mixed choral works bravely spanning
five centuries and including the likes of Holst, Copland and Eric Whitacre. The
choir’s sound – all clear diction and precise intonation – is top quality and
very English, while the balance between brass and voices is just right. Though
the songs themselves vary in quality, the performances throughout remain
consistently faultless.
No comments:
Post a Comment