Sisters: music by Rossini, Viardot, Gluck/Berlioz, Berlioz, Bertin, Bellini, Grandval, Saint-Saens; Karine Deshayes, Delphine Haidan, Orchestre national Avignon-Provence, conductor Débora Waldman; NoMadMusic
Reviewed 13 June 2025
Part celebration, part luxuriant delight: Malibran and Viardot celebrated in a programme that was clearly a joy for both soloists and performers, enjoyment, exploration and sheer virtuosic fun
From around 1825 to 1863 the sisters Maria Malibran (1808-1836) and Pauline Viardot (1821-1910) lit up the operatic stage. Both were daughters of Manuel García, a celebrated tenor much admired by Rossini (he created the role of Count Almaviva in The Barber of Seville), and their brother, also Manuel, was also a singer and pedagogue who invented the first laryngoscope.
Malibran was some 13 years the elder and it was only her early, tragic death that forced Viardot to become a professional singer. Viardot had wanted to become a professional pianist, she had had piano lessons with Liszt and harmony and counterpoint lessons with Reicha.
Viardot was just 15 when her sister died, so any idea of them singing together must be restricted to the realm of the personal, and to fantasy. Both singers had fascinatingly unquantifiable voices, large ranges so we might see them as mezzo-sopranos with high extension, both had their names linked to some remarkable roles.
The disc Sisters on NoMadMusic from mezzo-sopranos Karine Deshayes and Delphine Haidan, and the Orchestre national Avignon-Provence, conductor Débora Waldman, celebrates this sisterhood with a selection of bel canto classics that the sisters either sang or might have sang, with music from Rossini's Otello, La donna del lago, Elisabetta, regina d'Inghilterra and Semiramide, Viardot's own Le dernier sorcier, and Les Monts de Géorgie, Gluck's Orphée et Eurydice in the version arranged for Viardot by Berlioz, Berlioz' Les Troyens, initially written with Viardot in mind, Bertin's Fausto, Bellini's I Puritani, where the composer produced a special version for Malibran, Grandval's Mazeppa and a song by Saint-Saens.
The programme is described a panorama of Italian and French opera, but Rossini is its anchor. Some of Malibran's key Bellini roles are lacking, whilst Viardot is notable for having Sapho written for her by Gounod and more importantly she created the role of Fidès in Meyerbeer's Le prophète. What is does give us is a rather gorgeous and somewhat self-indulgent programme of arias and duets from two luxurious voices.