Saturday, 12 December 2020

Late Beethoven alongside Thomas Adès from the Solem Quartet at the latest of the imaginative concert series from Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo

Solem Quartet (Amy Tress, William Newell, Stephen Upshaw, Stephanie Tress) at Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo (Photo Matthew Johnson)
Solem Quartet (Amy Tress, William Newell, Stephen Upshaw, Stephanie Tress) at Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo (Photo Matthew Johnson)

Thomas Adès The Four Quarters, Beethoven String Quartet in B flat major, Op. 130; Solem Quartet; Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo

Reviewed by Robert Hugill on 12 December 2020 Star rating: 4.0 (★★★★)
The questing intelligence of late Beethoven alongside the superb contemporary maturity of Thomas Adès in the latest of this imaginative concert series

It is not surprising that Beethoven has featured in performances this year, but of the live performances since Spring it is interesting the Beethoven's late quartets seem to have featured. The Brodsky Quartet gave an interrupted series at Kings Place [I caught them in the Opus 135 quartet and Grosse Fugue], and the Solem Quartet is planning a Beethoven Bartok Now series combining late Beethoven with Bartok and contemporary pieces.

For the Solem Quartet's concert as part of the Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo on Friday 11 December 2020, the quartet combined Beethoven's String Quartet in B flat major, Op. 130 with Thomas Adès' The Four Quarters.

Solem Quartet (Amy Tress, William Newell, Stephen Upshaw, Stephanie Tress) at Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo (Photo Matthew Johnson)
Solem Quartet (Amy Tress, William Newell, Stephen Upshaw, Stephanie Tress) at Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo (Photo Matthew Johnson)

The Solem Quartet (Amy Tress, William Newell, Stephen Upshaw, Stephanie Tress) was founded at the University of Manchester in 2011, and the quartet's name comes from the university’s motto arduus ad solem – ‘striving towards the sun’.

Thomas Adès' The Four Quarters was written for the Emerson Quartet and premiered at the Carnegie Hall in 2011. The work is in four movements, Nightfalls, Serenade: Morning Dew, Days and The Twenty-fifth Hour and takes the listener through the diurnal cycle though, as we might expect from this composer, in an indirect and abstract way. 

Nightfalls began with music on two different planes, quiet bright violins in a regular pattern (short, short, long) and far below these, dark viola and cello in slow harmonies. It sounded as if it had always been going on,  highly evocative and magical. Throughout the movement there was a sense of the two planes coming together, coalescing and then receding, with moments of polyphonic textures coming alive with passion resulting in an intense, concentrated and thoughtful movement. Serenade: Morning Dew was more of a scherzo with furious, brilliant pizzicatos, the players bringing an amazing sense of intensity that was almost anger to the music. Again there was complex, polyphonic part-writing, and the complexity remained even when moving from pizzicato to arco. Days was quiet and intense, intertwining lines circling round a repeated note figure on the second violin which brought intensity. The repeated note increasingly dominated and took over the rhythm leading to powerful repeated chords, then everything unwound in highly transparent textures. Finally, The Twenty Fifth Hour, the time outside time, where we returned a high circular motion evoking the opening of the work and reminding me, somehow, of the dancing of the Sons of Morning in William Blake's Job. The music, however, developed into something stronger and very much full power before gradually unwinding.

Ignaz Schuppanzigh
Ignaz Schuppanzigh
Beethoven's Opus 130 quartet was written in 1826, it is the second of a trio of quartets originally commissioned in 1822 by Prince Galitzin but Beethoven's ill-health had delayed him. These would, ultimately, form the start of Beethoven's five late quartets. Most of this group were premiered by the Schuppanzigh Quartet led by Beethoven's friend Ignaz Schuppanzigh (1776-1830) who, back in the 1790s, had given the young composer violin lessons. When Beethoven started work on the commission from Prince Galitzin, he had not written a string quartet since 1810. The composer's conception of the form had changed, and listening to the Opus 130 quartet we are aware of how far Beethoven had taken the form from the late quartets of Haydn in just 25 years. 

For Opus 130, Beethoven takes the form of a serenade by using six movements rather than the usual four, but there is nothing light or conventional about this music and throughout the performance I was struck by Beethoven's restlessness of form. Even in movements which fit a securely conventional form, the composer never settles for long and one idea is constantly interrupting and disrupting another. You can understand why contemporaries found it puzzling, the music is a world away from the Beethoven of the Razumovsky Quartets (written in 1806) where he manipulates standard forms but always remains within them (just!).

We began with a slow introduction to draw you in, but even here Beethoven disrupts things and the fast and furious Allegro kept interrupting before it settled down into a perkily characterful movement. Yet the restlessness remained and the two compete with the players bringing a very strong contrast between the two. They made the complexities of Beethoven's counterpoint seem easy and obvious, making this a dialogue between friends, disagreements yes but never serious. The Presto was not quite a Scherzo, more tightly controlled and fast, full of strong contrasts and furious energy, and the questing here even seemed to stretch to the musical structure itself as the players brought out the sense of drama. The Andante was at first graceful, but then something more characterful with a feeling of emotional dialogue in the strong contrasts. There were moments of civilised music making, but never for long with strong interruptions.

The Alla danza tedesca was a world of lyrical charm, with a more pointed enervating middle section. But we didn't stay in this graceful world long, and the Cavatina was quiet and intense, the players bringing tension in the way they held the long lines. There was an almost hesitant quality to first violin Amy Tress' solo moments, the feeling that the form has not quite settled. Originally Beethoven wrote a mammoth final movement, a huge fugue but that seemed too big to Beethoven's contemporaries and it became a separate work, the Grosse Fugue Op.133, and he wrote a new, shorter movement though never heard the work in this revised form. I have heard the revised finale described as a short, light contredanse, but as played by the Solem Quartet this was anything but light. True, there was an endlessly inventive, rather perky dance with moments of sly wit, but the form was again constantly questing and each time the dance settled it would develop into something more challenging, complexity or passion would break out before the dance returned.

Solem Quartet (Amy Tress, William Newell, Stephen Upshaw, Stephanie Tress) at Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo (Photo Matthew Johnson)
Solem Quartet (Amy Tress, William Newell, Stephen Upshaw, Stephanie Tress) at Spotlight Chamber Concerts at St John's Waterloo (Photo Matthew Johnson)


In this music, Beethoven seems to be searching for a new type of form. Perhaps, as commentators say, his deafness led him to new areas. Or perhaps his illness led him to feel that he simply did not have time to stick to conventional niceties, but needed to explore territories of his own. The music certainly divided Beethoven's contemporaries, one said 'we know there is something there, but we do not know what it is' whilst the composer Louis Spohr referred to 'indecipherable, uncorrected horrors'. Quite simply, Beethoven didn't just break the rules, he made new ones and damned the consequences.

Elsewhere on this blog
  • Flexibility is her mantra: I chat to soprano Claire Booth about her recent film of Francis Poulenc's opera La voix humaine - interview
  • Òrain Ghàidhlig Beethoven: on the trail of the Scottish Gaelic origins of Beethoven's folk-song arrangements  - TV programme review
  • Cinderella in Leeds: Pauline Viardot's chamber opera in a new film from Northern Opera Group - opera film review
  • Back to its origins: Grange Park Opera returns Britten's television opera, Owen Wingrave, to its film roots in this darkly comic modern version - opera review
  • Immersive and intense: Schubert's Swan Song from Roderick Williams and friends at Spotlight Chamber Concerts - concert review
  • In the depths of deep despair: James Cleverton and Nigel Foster premiere Iain Bell's song cycle based on Thom Gunn's collection The Man with Night Sweats - concert review
  • Making music in complex times: conductor Cornelius Meister on his recent concerts in Scotland, his work with the opera in Stuttgart and national differences in performing styles  - interview
  • Rediscovering Handel's keyboard music for a new generation: Pierre Hantaï's disc of the 1720 Suites de Pièces - CD review
  • Christmas CD roundup: carols ancient, modern and medieval, Christmas in Puebla,  a Georgian trilogy and much more - CD review
  • A record dedicated to those who believe in ‘the holiness of the heart’s affections and the truth of imagination.’ - Bryce Morrison on Nelly Akopian-Tamarina's Slavonic Reflections - CD review
  • In Motion: United Strings of Europe's debut disc features three contemporary works alongside two classics in a strongly coloured programme  - CD review
  • Home

No comments:

Post a comment

Popular Posts this month